Comparison Test: Inexpensive Family Sedans  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

25th Place

24th Place

23rd Place

22nd Place

21st Place

20th Place

19th Place

18th Place

17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

10th Place: Subaru Legacy

  

The Legacy does not fit the normal family sedan convention. It is relatively small, relatively noisy and stiff-riding, and comes standard with all-wheel-drive rather than front-wheel-drive. If you are looking for all-weather traction at this price point, there is no better choice because there is no other choice. (AWD is now offered on versions of the Ford Fusion, but only versions priced well above the Legacy and this group’s price range.) It also offers good interior quality and sharp steering. But unless you are looking for all-wheel-drive, or are interested in the combination of quality with agility, you don’t need to put up with the Legacy’s shortcomings or with its relatively high price.

 

The Legacy has a firm and controlled ride, though more road imperfections can filter through than in the softer-tuned cars in this class. The car handles very well; the controlled body roll, the responsive, communicative steering, and the nimble feel make this one of the most fun midsize sedans. The weight of the all-wheel-drive system holds back the 2.5-liter 4-cylinder, it could use additional power in virtually every circumstance despite a recent upgrade. The higher-priced turbocharged version of that engine is much quicker. The engine is noisy under hard acceleration, and sounds a bit harsh. Road noise is also prevalent. Gas mileage is also diminished by the all-wheel-drive system, but is still reasonable by this group’s standards.

 

Inside, the Legacy’s front seats are a bit low and there could be more headroom, but they are firm, well-shaped, and very comfortable. The rear is cramped, but the seat is well-shaped. The attractive interior uses high-quality materials that fit together very well. The gauges are clear, but some instruments could be larger. Drivers sit comfortably, and can see out well. Rear seat entry/exit is complicated by narrow door openings and small footwells. The trunk is smaller than that in most compact cars. 

 

The Legacy reviewed here came in at $20,794, with satellite radio and its standard equipment, which includes all-wheel-drive, active head restraints, and alloy wheels.

 

Overall, the Legacy is not the roomiest car in this class, nor the cheapest, nor the most comfortable-riding. But it brings a premium feel to this price range, the feel of an upscale sport sedan. With nimble handling, a high-quality interior, and a rare all-wheel-drive system, it feels like it costs a lot more than $21,000, but for most people shopping in this class, there are better choices.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicles Reviewed:

 2007 Subaru Legacy

 2.5i

 2.5-liter H4 (175 hp)

 4-speed automatic

 $20,794

 

  Pros:

-AWD

-Handling

-Safety Ratings

-Interior Quality

 

 Cons:

-Interior Space

-Price

-Ride

-Refinement

-Trunk Space

 

 Overall: 7/10

A great car for those interested in its specific strengths, but it lacks broad appeal.

 

 

 

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2007, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research