Comparison Test: Inexpensive Family Sedans  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

25th Place

24th Place

23rd Place

22nd Place

21st Place

20th Place

19th Place

18th Place

17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

13th Place: Nissan Altima

  

The Nissan Altima was redesigned for 2007, but in some ways its predecessor was superior. Though the new version features a much-improved powertrain, a strong engine coupled to a well-designed continuously variable transmission to achieve the best gas mileage in this group; improved ride and handling, and a nicer interior, Nissan cut into the rear seat space for the benefit of the car’s styling, and raised the price. It’s one of the more fun to drive family sedans, but it’s not as practical nor as inexpensive as it once was and as the competition is.

 

The Altima rides comfortably. The ride is very well-controlled yet still absorbent. It handles nimbly, and the steering is responsive and communicative for a midsize sedan. However, the Altima is larger and not as sharp as the Mazda6. It’s more powerful though, with a 4-cylinder strong enough to beat many competing V6s. The CVT can be shifted manually between set automatic gear ratios, or left to maintain maximum efficiency. The 4-cylinder is neither particularly smooth nor quiet, but wind and road noise are well-suppressed. As noted, gas mileage is excellent, particularly considering the car’s acceleration.

 

Inside, the Altima’s front seats are reasonably spacious and comfortable, but the rear is too low and lacking in leg and foot space. The previous-generation Altima had a very roomy rear seat, a benefit that has been deleted in the name of sleeker styling. The interior is well-constructed, with well-fitting and high-quality materials. The gauges are clear and the instruments are logically arrayed. Drivers sit comfortably enough, but could have better rearward visibility. The trunk is large and well-shaped.

 

The Altima reviewed here came in at $20,872, not particularly well-equipped. It does include standard features like a tire-pressure monitor, active head restraints, a keyless starting system, and a trip computer, but traction and stability control are only available on V6 versions, and adding other options found on most of the others here would push the price over this group’s limit.

 

Overall, the Altima is a very nice car with too many flaws to command one of the group’s highest prices. Most disappointing is that the biggest shortcoming, a cramped rear seat, was easily avoidable by a subtle restyle, which also could have improved visibility. Perhaps with the rear seat space of the previous-generation Altima, this new model could have overcome its price advantage to be one of the higher-ranked cars in this group. But when fun-to-drive cars like the Mazda6 and Honda Accord offer an adult-friendly back seat and sharper handling for less money, it is hard to bill the Altima as more than a runner-up.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2007 Nissan Altima

 2.5S

 2.5-liter I4 (175 hp)

 CVT 

 $20,872

 

  Pros:

-Fuel Economy

-Handling

-Interior Quality

-Acceleration

-Trunk Space

 

 Cons:

-Price

-Rear Seat

 

 Overall: 7/10

A nice fun-to-drive midsize sedan, but too expensive and not roomy enough to be one of the best family sedans.

 

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2007, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research