Comparison Test: Midsize Pickups  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

1st Place: Toyota Tacoma

 

The Tacoma strikes an excellent blend between the qualities of a car and a truck. It rides and handles well, has a roomy, comfortable, and high-quality interior, has the longest bed in this group, and rivals the two V8-powered pickups in this group for the highest towing capacity. At over $27,000, it’s no roaring value, but if you’re looking for the best blend of virtues in this class, it’s worth it.

 

The Tacoma has a smooth, stable, and very comfortable ride that loses some finesse and on poorer pavement. It handles well for a pickup, but it the steering, though acceptably responsive, lacks feedback and feels a bit vague. Generally, it is easy to drive more than it is actually fun. The Tacoma is the quickest vehicle in this group, and the V6 is smooth, refined, and relatively fuel-efficient. Wind noise is excessive, however. The Tacoma is rated to tow an impressive 6,500 lbs.

 

Inside, the Tacoma’s front seats are roomy and well-shaped, but could be higher. The rear seat could be higher as well, and the shape leaves occupants sitting a bit upright. The rear seat folds to open up a roomy interior cargo area second only to the Ford Sport Trac in this group. The Tacoma offers a class-exclusive long-bed option, which at over six feet long, is more than eight inches longer than the next-longest Dodge Dakota. The long bed costs only $500, and is recommended for the usability it adds. The interior uses some hard plastics, but all trim pieces look suitably upscale and fit together very well. The gauges are large and clear, but some instruments could be larger. Drivers sit comfortably, but a higher seat would improve visibility. Entry/exit is easy.   

The Tacoma reviewed here came in at $27,453, missing satellite radio, a power driver’s seat, and a sunroof. It did include a tire-pressure monitor at that price, but is not one of the better-equipped vehicles in this group.

 

Overall, the Tacoma is a pleasant truck that also provides excellent functionality, and its lack of serious vices combine with that and its combination of excellent acceleration and decent gas mileage. It is not an inexpensive truck, and is not the most comfortable or fun to drive in this class. But nothing else in this class offers the same level of pickup-truck usability and respectable comfort and driving manners. If that’s what you want, the Tacoma is your best bet, even at its somewhat high price.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2006 Toyota Tacoma

 Long Bed

 4.0-liter V6 (236 hp)

 5-speed automatic

 $27,453

 

  Pros:

-Bed Length

-Towing Capacity

-Ride Comfort

-Acceleration

-Fuel Economy

-Safety Ratings

-Interior Space

-Agility

-Interior Quality

 

 Cons:

-Price

-Low Seats

 

 Overall:

The best blend of comfort and functionality in this group.           

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2006, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research