Comparison Test: Midsize Pickups  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

3rd Place: Nissan Frontier

 

The Frontier blends fair pricing, surprisingly enjoyable handling, impressive power, and good towing capacity. Though it is a traditional truck-based design, the handling-biased suspension makes it more fun to drive than Honda’s car-based Ridgeline, which leaves the Frontier with a stiffer, less absorbent ride than its competitors. It also lacks rear seat space, the flaw that, if corrected, would have given this capable pickup a wide-margin win in this comparison.

 

As noted, the Frontier rides stiffly, and slams its way over larger bumps. But it always recovers quickly at least, and is stable and reasonably comfortable on smooth surfaces. It handles quite well for a pickup, with restrained body roll and quick steering that even provides good feedback, making it the sportiest vehicle in this group. Its V6 is powerful, and though it isn’t exactly quiet, it sounds pleasant. Road noise could be better-suppressed, but isn’t obtrusive. The Frontier is rated to tow up to 6,100 lbs. Gas mileage is within the range of this group, but doesn’t especially impress.

 

Inside, the Frontier’s front seats are high, well-shaped, and quite comfortable, and there is sufficient head and leg space. If only the same were true of the rear. While the seat is reasonably well-shaped, it is rather small and mounted low, and there is still a lack of leg and head space. Unless the occupants of the front seats are especially short, not even two adults will fit with any comfort in the rear. The versatile seat can either flip up or fold down, but neither way opens up as much interior cargo space as some of the others. A fold-flat front passenger seat helps, and the bed is appropriately sized for this class. The interior uses mostly hard, cheap-feeling plastics, but they fit together well. The gauges are clear and the instruments are well-placed and easy to use, though some are a bit small. Drivers sit comfortably and have clear visibility. Entry/exit is complicated by narrow door openings, particularly to the rear seat.

 

The Frontier reviewed here came in at $26,809, well-equipped. Though it doesn’t have a power driver’s seat, it does come with active head restraints, a tire-pressure monitor, a roof rack, and hill ascent/descent control.

 

The Frontier is a very competitive pickup, but its lack of rear seat space prevents it from being an especially good family vehicle. The stiff ride and low-budget interior aren’t great either. But it offers competitive pricing, good safety ratings, comfortable front seating, a competitive towing capacity, excellent acceleration, and nimble handling. If you don’t need a comfortable rear seat, it’s the best choice in this group.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2006 Nissan Frontier LE

 4.0-liter V6 (265 hp)

 5-speed automatic

 $26,809

 

  Pros:

-Price

-Acceleration

-Towing Capacity

-Agility

-Safety Ratings

 

 Cons:

-Interior Space

-Ride Comfort

-Interior Quality

 

 Overall:

A roomy rear seat away from winning this comparison.             

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2006, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research