Comparison Test: Midsize Pickups  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations


 

 

5th Place: Ford Sport Trac V6

4th Place: Ford Sport Trac V8

 

The redesigned-for-2007 Sport Trac is Ford’s Explorer SUV with a bed instead of an enclosed cargo area and third-row seat. The rest is shared between them. For this reason, it is not surprising that the Sport Trac has many of the same qualities and faults as the Explorer: it is comfortable, reasonably quiet, and safe, but not agile or especially high-quality inside. But in the conversion process from SUV to pickup, the Sport Trac ended up with a bed that is over ten inches shorter than the next-smallest Chevrolet Colorado, and nearly two feet shorter than the group-leading Toyota Tacoma. It’s one of the pricier vehicles in this group as well. But for its blend of passenger comfort and refinement with a high towing capacity, it is worth a good look.

 

The Sport Trac has a very comfortable, absorbent ride by this group’s standards, though it can be prone to high-speed floaty motions and isn’t quite as smooth as the Explorer. Despite its lower weight, it feels no less clumsy in corners than the heavier Explorer, and the overboosted steering is completely numb, though adequately responsive. The standard V6 provides adequate acceleration off the line, but lacks extra passing punch. The V8 is much quicker, the Sport Trac’s mass prevents it from feeling quicker than some competing V6 models, particularly from a stop. The V6 model can tow up to 5,140 pounds, capable by this group’s standards, and the V8 can tow 1,500 more, and is probably much better at it. The rough-sounding V6 roars under acceleration, the V8 sounds much better. Wind and road noise are acceptably muted. The V8’s six-speed automatic transmission helps minimize the gas mileage deficit compared to the V6, but neither have especially good fuel economy for this class.

 

Inside, the Sport Trac’s front seats are large and comfortable, though they could be a bit firmer and could use some extra lateral support. The rear is roomy, but the cushion should be mounted higher. The rear seat folds flat to offer the most in-cab cargo space in this group, but that can’t hope to make up for a bed that is by far the smallest. The three in-bed cargo boxes are convenient but small. The interior is generally well-constructed, but a few cheap materials and instances of poor panel fit limit the effectiveness of those strong points in providing an overall feeling of quality. The gauges are adequately clear, but the odd instrument panel leaves the climate controls too low and the audio controls too high. Drivers sit high and comfortably, but rearward visibility would be clearer with slimmer roof pillars. Entry/exit is easy.

 

The Sport Trac V6 was one of the more expensive vehicles in this group at $28,290, and the V8 was the most expensive at $29,181, identically equipped. The two Sport Tracs were the only two vehicles in this group to have all of the expected features listed on the introduction page, and also came with power adjustable pedals, a tire-pressure monitor, rollover sensors, and Ford’s exclusive keypad entry system.

 

The V8 has a relatively small cost over the V6 in price and gas mileage, and outranks that model for its improved towing capacity, acceleration, and refinement. And overall, the Sport Trac’s refinement, ride comfort, excellent safety ratings, and roomy interior make it a good family-friendly pickup, and despite its tiny bed, the impressive towing capacity makes it a more capable family vehicle than its closest competitor, the Honda Ridgeline. It doesn’t have the agility, gas mileage, or interior quality of some competitors, the V6 is a bit weak and noisy, it isn’t inexpensive, and the size of the bed could easily be a deal-breaker for many potential buyers, but it does a reasonable job at bringing the virtues of the Ford Explorer to this group, and is worth a look from consumers looking for a capable pickup to use as a family vehicle and who are aware of its shortcomings.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicles Reviewed:

 2007 Ford Sport Trac

 XLT

 4.0-liter V6 (210 hp)

 5-speed automatic

 $28,290

 

 2007 Ford Sport Trac

 XLT

 4.6-liter V8 (292 hp)

 6-speed automatic

 $29,181

 

  Pros:

-Interior Comfort

-Towing Capacity (V8)

-Ride Comfort

-Safety Ratings

-Acceleration (V8)

-Refinement

 

 Cons:

-Bed Size

-Price

-Agility

 

 Overall:

A good blend of everyday usability and pickup truck capability that needs some detail updates and a lower price.

 

 Vehicle Overview            

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2006, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research