Comparison Test: Premium Midsize Sedans  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details
21st Place

20th Place
19th Place
18th Place
17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations
 

 

10th Place: Subaru Legacy

 

The Legacy is one of the more expensive cars in this group, and a rather unique one. Especially in the turbocharged GT versions, it is no typical family sedan. Its firm ride leads to impressive agility, and it has a group-exclusive all-wheel-drive system as part of its standard equipment. The interior is comfortable, but smaller than most of the other cars in this group. While it is not a real alternative to the traditional family sedans, its unique attributes present an alternative to their respective strong and weak points.

 

The Legacy has a firm, controlled, and generally comfortable ride, though more road imperfections can filter through than in the softer-tuned cars in this class. Base Legacy versions are more absorbent. The car handles very well, the controlled body roll, the responsive, communicative steering, and the nimble feel make this one of the more fun family sedans. The weight of the all-wheel-drive system holds back this version’s turbocharged 2.5-liter 4-cylinder, and it suffers from off-the-line lag, but is powerful by this group’s standards overall. The engine whines under acceleration. Wind noise is well-suppressed, road noise is somewhat obtrusive. A combination of the AWD system and the high-power engine diminish fuel economy.

 

Inside, the Legacy’s front seats are a bit low, and there could be more headroom, but the firm, well-shaped seats are very comfortable. The rear is also well-shaped, but it would need more leg and head space to be considered truly comfortable. The attractive interior uses high-quality materials that fit together very well. The gauges are very clear, and the instruments are logically placed and easy to use, though they could use more contrast. Drivers sit comfortably, and can see out well. Rear seat entry/exit is complicated by narrow door openings and small footwells. The trunk is smaller than that in most compact cars, and is easily the smallest in this group.

 

NHTSA has not crash tested the Legacy, but the Subaru Outback (a slightly modified Legacy station wagon) earned five stars across the board. The Legacy also did exceptionally well in IIHS testing. It earned the Best Pick rating in both its offset and side crash test, and its head restraints were rated Good.

 

The Legacy reviewed here came in at $27,249, as one of the higher-priced cars in this group. At that price, it includes the standard all-wheel-drive (as have every other recent Subaru) and front-seat active head restraints, but no stability control or satellite radio.

 

Overall, the Legacy is a blend of premium and fun qualities. It isn’t roomy, inexpensive, or refined, but it is very safe, very quick, and enjoyable to drive, and has a high-quality interior. Cross-shop with the Volkswagen Passat, Acura TSX, and Mazda6 before you do a more mainstream competitor, and get more fun than the former and more luxury than the latter.

  

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2006 Subaru Legacy

 2.5GT Limited

 2.5-liter H4 (250 hp)

 5-speed automatic

 $27,249

 

  Pros:

-Acceleration

-Agility

-Standard AWD

-Interior Quality

-Safety Ratings

 

 Cons:

-Price

-Trunk Space

-Ride Comfort

-Fuel Economy

-Refinement

-Rear Seat Space

 

 Overall:

A worthy choice for consumers looking either for driving enjoyment or all-weather traction. 

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2006, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research