Comparison Test: Premium Midsize Sedans  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details
21st Place

20th Place
19th Place
18th Place
17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations
 

 

11th Place: Volkswagen Passat

 

The Passat was just redesigned for 2006 with key differences being a roomier interior, more powerful engines, and higher prices. The 4-cylinder Passat is now as quick as most V6 competitors, but is just as expensive. It rides and handles well, but the previous version achieved a better balance. And while interior space has improved, it is still not a roomy vehicle. This new Passat is generally a very nice car, but it has its issues, and is rather expensive.

 

The Passat has a firm, controlled, and generally comfortable ride, though it does not filter bumps especially well. The car handles capably, but despite the accurate and responsive steering it is not as enjoyable to drive as its predecessor. The 2.0-liter turbocharged I4, shared with the Audi A3 and A4, provides comparable acceleration to competing V6 models, but is a bit slow off the line and not as linear as this class’s more traditional engine. It’s not quiet, but it never sounds strained. Wind and road noise are adequately suppressed. Despite its acceleration, the Passat manages excellent fuel economy.

 

Inside, the Passat’s front seats have a long cushion and good head space, but could use more lateral support and more leg space. The rear seat is roomier than the previous model’s, but the seat cushion is flat and lumpy, and there ought to be more foot space beneath the front seats. The dash uses high-quality materials, though they aren’t as meticulously assembled as its predecessor’s. Ergonomics have improved however, with clearer gauges and simpler automatic climate controls. The odd mix of manual and automatic seat controls is somewhat irksome. Drivers sit very comfortably, but rearward visibility is impeded by the three large rear head restraints and thick roof pillars. Wide door openings help entry/exit. The trunk is small but well-shaped.

 

The Passat’s new design abundance of standard safety features should have given it better-than-average NHTSA crash test results, but its fours stars for both the driver and for the front passenger is mediocre for this class. Its five stars for the driver and four for the rear passenger in the side crash test stand up better against competitors. It does shine in IIHS evaluations, earning Good ratings for frontal and side protection and an Acceptable head restraint score.

 

The Passat is not inexpensive, even in its 4-cylinder version it came in at $26,521. (The V6 version was well out of this group’s price range.) And despite the marketing surrounding the car’s standard features, it doesn’t stand out there either. It does include a tire-pressure monitor and (optional) side airbags that protect the torsos of rear occupants. But even with sticker prices past $30,000, no version of the 4-cylinder Passat offers full-power front seats, offering power lumbar and recline functions for both passengers but manual fore-aft and height adjustments, an odd oversight. 

 

Overall, the new Passat is less unique than its predecessor, while not being much more desirable. Attempts to convert it into more of a mainstream family sedan have not really succeeded, while they have diminished the car’s former ride/handling compromise. But there is still a lot to like here, like the powerful and fuel-efficient I4 that exceeds the previous Passat’s V6 in both areas, the excellent IIHS crash test results, and a decent blend of interior space, ride comfort, and agility. It’s not a great mainstream car, but a decent alternative to one with a dash of sport.

  

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2006 Volkswagen Passat

 2.0T

 2.0-liter I4 (200 hp)

 6-speed automatic

 $26,521 

 

  Pros:

-Acceleration

-Agility

-Fuel Economy

-Interior Quality

-Safety Ratings

 

 Cons:

-Price

-Trunk Space

-Seat Adjustments

 

 Overall:

The new Passat is a combination of the flaws of its predecessor with the flaws of a mainstream sedan that somehow works.

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2006, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research