Comparison Test: Premium Midsize Sedans  
 

Introduction

Vehicle Details
21st Place

20th Place
19th Place
18th Place
17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place
Evaluations
 

 

3rd Place: Hyundai Sonata

 

Look at the IFCAR Best-In-Class ratings and the recent $20,000 family sedan comparison, and you will see that the new-for-2006 Hyundai Sonata took top honors in both areas. What happened? Value plays a much larger role in the lower-end midsize market, also the center of greater market activity (read: sales) than that of the fully-loaded models. The Sonata has value down, coming in well-equipped with the lowest price in this group. It also is a very good car, with a roomy interior, comfortable ride, agile handling, and no strong demerits. But  for all its excellence and value, it can’t provide the feeling of true luxury like some competitors can. The Sonata is an excellent choice for the budget minded shopper looking for a very good car with nice features, but it’s not going to be called the best premium family sedan.

 

The Sonata has a comfortable ride, but the base models without this LX’s 17-inch tires are more absorbent without a handling penalty. The car handles well with either tires, contained body roll in fast cornering, responsive, well-weighted, and accurate steering that returns good feedback. It isn’t quite as enjoyable to drive as the Honda Accord (and well behind its sport-focused competitors like the Mazda6 or Acura TSX) but it is now on a similar level. The 3.3-liter V6 is quick and refined, but leads the group in neither power nor refinement. Wind noise is well-suppressed, road noise less so. Fuel economy is very good by this group’s standards.

 

Inside, the Sonata’s front seats are high, well-shaped, supportive, and very comfortable, and there is plenty of head space even with the optional sunroof. The rear is also very roomy, and the seat is high and well-shaped there as well. The dash uses high-quality materials that fit together very well, but doesn’t have the premium look or feel found in several competitors. The gauges are clear, and the instruments are well-placed and easy to use. Drivers sit comfortably, and visibility is excellent, thanks to high seating and particularly large windows with narrow roof pillars. The high roof, wide door openings, and large rear footwells contribute to very easy entry/exit. The trunk is roomy and well-shaped.

 

The Sonata earned five stars for both the driver and for the front passenger in the NHTSA frontal crash test, and five stars for both the driver and for the rear passenger in the NHTSA side crash test. It was Good in the IIHS offset crash test and Acceptable in the side crash test. Its head restraints were rated Good.

 

The Sonata reviewed here came fully loaded with every option for the lowest price in this group: $22,885. However, even fully loaded, it lacks a power passenger’s seat and satellite radio.

 

Overall, the Sonata may be the least-expensive vehicle in this group, and it is a very competent midsize sedan, but it doesn’t have the premium feel of a number of the other fully-loaded sedans. It matches or exceeds most like-priced competitors in that area, but if you’re willing to spend more, you’re likely to get more. If you don’t see a problem with the level of luxury in the Sonata, and it certainly doesn’t come up completely short in that area, buy it for its exceptional safety ratings, roomy interior, good ride and handling, good power and fuel economy, and excellent value.

 

 

The Basics:

 

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2006 Hyundai Sonata

 3.3-liter V6 (235 hp)

 5-speed automatic

 $22,885

 

  Pros:

-Ride Comfort

-Price

-Interior Space

-Acceleration

-Fuel Economy

-Safety Ratings

 

 Cons:

-Little Luxury Feel

 

 Overall:

The best value in this group, but at a cost.           

  

IFCAR Home

Reviews

Pricing

Other Sources

Top Picks

Vehicle Info

About IFCAR

Contact IFCAR

© 2006, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research