Get email updates from IFCAR.

Comparison Test: Economy Sedans

 

 

Introduction
Vehicle Details

17th Place

16th Place

15th Place

14th Place

13th Place

12th Place

11th Place

10th Place

9th Place

8th Place

7th Place

6th Place

5th Place

4th Place

3rd Place

2nd Place

1st Place

Evaluations

12th Place: Mitsubishi Lancer

 


Overview:

The Lancer, freshly redesigned for 2008, has won praise for its newly sharp handling and newly sharp styling. But like its predecessor, the new Lancer doesn't have a whole lot going for it, providing an overall feeling of cheapness without an especially low price. The engine is harsh and noisy and the interior is poorly constructed from low-quality materials. Fuel economy is also below par. But the Lancer's responsive handling makes it more fun to drive than most of its competitors. If that matters to you and the Lancer's $16,831 maxes out your budget, it may be worth a look, but otherwise, look elsewhere.

 

Driving the Lancer:

The Lancer has a stiff ride that doesn't absorb bumps well. Its suspension is obviously tuned more for handling; the car corners nimbly with minimal body lean and sharp, quick steering. The fun-to-drive quotient would be much stronger if the powertrain were at the performance level of the suspension, but the Lancer feels generally weak and its continuously variable transmission keeps the harsh engine running at high rpms. It does feel slower than it is, but it's still not quick, particularly off the line. Road and engine noise are constant irritants. Gas mileage is poor for this class.

 

Inside the Lancer:

The Lancer's front seats are low, but well-shaped, supportive, and comfortable overall. The rear, however, is too low, and there should still be more headroom. The interior feels very cheap, with low-grade ill-fitting plastic trim pieces and particularly tinny-sounding doors. The gauges are very clear at least, and the instruments are logically arrayed. Drivers sit comfortably enough, but would benefit from a telescoping steering column. Visibility is largely unimpeded to the front and rear. Higher seats would ease entry/exit, and rear access would be simpler with larger door openings. The trunk is small, but reasonably well-shaped.

 

Lancer pricing:

The Lancer is not inexpensive, coming in at $16,831, but it is well-equipped at that price, with the group's expected features as well as a knee-protecting driver airbag and alloy wheels.

 

Conclusion:

The general feel of the new Lancer has not changed in the redesign: it still feels junky. However, its sharp handling gives it some potential appeal. Consider it if driving fun is important to you, but shop it carefully against other nimble economy cars before paying close to $17,000 to deal with its overall low-rent feel.

 

NEXT PAGE

 

  

 Vehicle Reviewed:

 2008 Mitsubishi Lancer

 ES

 2.0-liter I4

 CVT

 $16,831

 

  Pros:

-Handling

 

 Cons:

-Ride comfort

-Refinement

-Fuel economy

-Interior quality

-Rear seat comfort

-Trunk space

 

 Overall: 6/10

The Lancer is fun to drive, but unless you're enjoying fast cornering you're left with a thoroughly mediocre car.

 

 Why it didn't win:

Cheap inside, unrefined, and not inexpensive. Doing one thing well isn't enough.

 

 Recommended: NO

 

 
© 2008, Institute For Consumer Automotive Research